This article is featured in The D.C. Brief, TIME’s newsletter on politics. Subscribe here to receive similar stories directly in your inbox.
To understand the current turmoil affecting both major political parties, it’s worth considering an unexpected player: Matt Gaetz, the contentious former House representative and failed contender for Donald Trump’s Attorney General position.
Recent reports suggest that the House Ethics Committee is poised to release its findings on Gaetz shortly. It’s important to note that Gaetz resigned from his congressional seat last November, mere hours before the ethics committee was due to publish an investigation that raised alarming questions about his conduct involving minors, financial dealings, substance abuse, and inappropriate conversations. These serious allegations played a crucial role in his decision to withdraw from the race for the country’s top law enforcement role.
In reaction to the ongoing scrutiny, Gaetz issued a comprehensive statement proclaiming his innocence against what he labeled as baseless accusations, shifting the focus to his fellow party members. “My 30s involved a lot of hard work and hard partying,” he shared on X. “While I may have indulged a bit too much, that’s not a crime. At least I didn’t endorse spending bills that jeopardize our country!” Despite stepping back, he continues to create challenges for the passage of critical continuing resolutions needed to keep the government functioning.
It remains to be seen whether the upcoming report will impact Gaetz’s position in the political arena. Just last week, One America News Network revealed that he will be hosting a nightly talk show on its strongly pro-Trump platform. Although it trails behind Fox News and Newsmax in viewership, it holds considerable sway among Trump supporters, including Trump himself, who frequently endorses its conspiracy-driven narratives.
Adding another layer to the story, Politico disclosed that Gaetz is in talks to join a well-known personal injury law firm headed by a significant Democratic donor who has been openly critical of President Biden’s re-election campaign.
The interest from such diverse organizations in Gaetz is noteworthy, particularly considering that the allegations against him have been publicly known for years.
Much like Trump, Gaetz seems to operate under the belief that he can simply disregard the allegations without facing consequences. While his resignation from Congress may have provided temporary protection from scrutiny, the House Ethics Committee has opted to proceed with its investigation, potentially indicating a desire to challenge the prevailing culture of impunity associated with figures like Gaetz.
Amidst all of this, Gaetz may well symbolize the future trajectory of the Republican Party as it navigates the complexities of a post-Trump world.
Moreover, some speculate that Gaetz possesses political skills that could be advantageous to Democrats in their strategic planning.
Both views may have merit or could be overstated. Nevertheless, the serious contemplation of these notions underscores the significant uncertainty both major parties are grappling with today. This climate of uncertainty is prompting lobbyists along K Street to expand their networks this holiday season, just in case their predictions turn out to be incorrect. Consulting firms are also diversifying by hiring both traditional GOP players and MAGA supporters while maintaining their Democratic ties for the time being.
The Republicans regained control last month, largely due to Trump and his wealthy allies, including Elon Musk. The GOP is positioned to dominate the White House, the Senate, and maintain a narrow majority in the House—one that could diminish further if Trump successfully installs loyalists in critical national security and diplomatic roles. Addressing Trump’s sway, House Speaker Mike Johnson remarked, “Enough already,” concerning Trump’s attempts to consolidate power within his fragile caucus.
Democrats are pushing back against any assertions of a Republican mandate as they head into the upcoming year. However, unlike eight years ago when grassroots activists united under The Resistance banner, there is no similar movement surfacing now. In fact, the Democratic base seems somewhat demoralized, which could explain why prominent donor John Morgan, who claims his law firm is the largest personal injury practice in the country, is looking to recruit Gaetz.
The current political landscape is so unpredictable that almost anything seems feasible. Trump’s last-ditch efforts for power raise questions about whether his influence will persist beyond his tenure. The Reagan Revolution dissipated following his departure, and there was little enthusiasm within the GOP for a post-presidency role for either Bush 41 or 43. While Trump has managed to regain influence, it remains uncertain if anyone in the MAGA sphere can replicate his intensity—whether it’s Vice President-elect J.D. Vance, Don Jr., or any other potential successor.
On the Democratic front, clarity is equally elusive. Biden’s likely departure and Kamala Harris’s recent challenges leave a substantial gap regarding the party’s future direction. Biden appears to have largely withdrawn from the political conversation in Washington as he and his team count down their remaining days in office. Meanwhile, Harris has begun laying the groundwork for her next moves, recently encouraging supporters at her Washington residence with remarks like, “We do not let anything defeat us” and “We are not having a pity party.” Conversations about the future of the Democratic National Committee and its associated organizations are intensifying. However, enthusiasm seems lacking for figures like Barack Obama or the Clintons, and a former Democratic House member with controversial opinions is gearing up to take on a significant role in the Trump Administration. Morgan, the major Democratic donor interested in hiring Gaetz, asserts that Harris’s political career is nearing its end.
Can you witness the chaos that is unfolding?
The fact that Gaetz—a provocateur who challenges the establishment in both parties—is viewed as a potential stabilizing force during these tumultuous times is noteworthy. Republicans may see him as a loyalist who nearly ascended to leadership in a legal battle against Trump’s opponents, while Democrats understandably view him as a disgraced figure. Both perspectives can coexist, and public perception may soon categorize him as an unconvicted criminal, contingent on the upcoming ethics committee revelations.
On December 12, Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska voiced concerns from within the GOP’s remaining MAGA faction, stating, “I’ve made no secret of the fact that I align more with Ronald Reagan than with Trump.” While she does not support Gaetz, she is still contemplating some of Trump’s contentious nominees, such as the “compromised” former Rep. Tulsi Gabbard and the accused sexual assaulter Pete Hegseth. Aware of the potential backlash from her right flank, Murkowski embraced her identity as a political survivor and a steady voice against the mob mentality, asserting, “Call me whatever you want.”
What else might people label her? Perhaps as a reliable barometer, even an early warning system. She may be predicting how loyalty to Trump’s choices—Gaetz at the forefront—will affect their standing within the party. “We’re getting a glimpse of what it means to be loyal to [the] party, and I don’t think that will serve us well as Republicans,” Murkowski cautioned. “I believe it will energize and galvanize the Democrats.” This is why Democrats are at least curious about how someone like Gaetz can navigate multiple factions at once.
Stay updated on the latest happenings in Washington. Subscribe to the D.C. Brief newsletter.
